The process of finding the appropriate running shoes for overpronation can prove challenging given the vast array of brands that exist. Additionally, it can be difficult to determine whether or not stability shoes are necessary.
It's important to note that everyone experiences some degree of pronation while running, which is a natural and necessary occurrence. Before assuming that you require a stability shoe, it's essential to ask yourself if you've been experiencing any pain or issues while running.
It's vital to recognize that those working at running stores merely observe your foot movement instead of looking at your overall leg movement, which could include a hip drop that leads to your knee and foot rolling inward. In such a situation, a stability shoe won't solve the problem.
Pronation in running refers to the inward or outward rolling of your foot while running. Everyone has some pronation, and this is a positive development. According to Podiatrists, the average person should experience about 15% or less pronation in their step. When you land, your ankle and arch will slightly collapse into the ground to absorb the shock of that impact. Your foot then rolls from heel to forefoot, resulting in more weight on your big toe. Your big toe plays a crucial role in the quick push-off from the ground.
The degree to which your foot rolls inward or outward determines your pronation type and assists in guiding any necessary changes. Overpronation is when your foot rolls too far inward, while neutral pronation is when there's little to no excessive rolling either inward or outward upon landing. Underpronation or supination happens when your foot doesn't roll inward enough or even rolls outward.
It's crucial to determine whether or not you require a stability shoe. Overpronation can cause arch fall, leading to your ankle rolling in and causing strain in the knee and hip regions, which can result in injury. Checking your shoe wear used to be a helpful indicator of overpronation, but that's no longer accurate. The best method is to visit a physical therapist who can observe your stride and ensure that the correcting shoe isn't required due to weak hips letting your knee and ankle collapse inward. Filming yourself in slow motion could work, but without the appropriate knowledge of what to look for, you could still miss the root cause of the problem.
It's advisable to focus on exercises that strengthen your weak hips, glutes, and core before relying on shoes to correct issues. Failure to do so will lead to developing weak areas, thereby masking issues for shorter periods. When your foot strikes roll too far outward or lack adequate mobility, you become prone to various woes due to the excessive force exerted on the joints, tendons, and overworked muscles.
A 2019 study published in Frontiers in Physiology revealed that elite runners possess greater foot stability. This could be the reason why they're better equipped to avoid running-related injuries now that we understand the significance of a foot in the kinetic chain.
It's crucial to understand the role of a stability running shoe. While ankles and feet are meant to move to some degree, you may experience some pronation but not require a stability shoe. Stability shoes tend to feel firmer, lack a cushioned feeling, and are sometimes over-recommended to runners who need to work on their hip and glute strength.
In order to work on strength and move away from shoes that correct imbalances, try alternating between neutral and stability shoes. While stability and neutral running shoes share some characteristics, they also differ from each other in terms of their midsole construction, which includes supportive features like a medial post or guide rails.
A medial post is made of denser EVA foam, which provides support to slow down the rate of overpronation during your gait cycle. Traditionally, this has been the method of adding support to shoes. These supportive features help to maintain your foot in a neutral position. Stability shoes with this design are a great option for runners with mild to moderate overpronation. However, the drawback of these shoes is that they tend to be slightly heavier.
Once the root cause has been addressed, you can consider some shoe recommendations. Check out the Asics Gel-Kayano, which is known for its supportive, multi-density midsole and firmer foam through the arch. The DuoMax Support System is the perfect fit for overpronators, as it helps the foot land in a more neutral position. The shoe is designed to be a stability shoe for overpronators, but it's also popular with high-mileage neutral runners. The newest model is the 29, but if you find an older model on sale, it's still a great choice.
Nike also offers the Air Zoom Structure and Infinity Run for runners looking for supportive shoes. While Nike doesn't make many stability shoes, both the Infinity React Run Flyknit and Zoom Structure offer amazing cushioning. The Nike Air Zoom Structure 24 has ditched the medial post that the 23 had, but it's still a support-oriented running shoe with a wide midsole and a snug-fitting upper.
Looking for a running shoe that offers support without compromising on flexibility or cushioning? Look no further than the Nike React Infinity Run Flyknit 3. This shoe, designed for runners with flexible flat feet, is a supportive-neutral option that is perfect for those who want a little extra support without going for a full stability or motion-control shoe.
One of the key features of the React Infinity Run Flyknit 3 is its innovative guide rail system, which is similar to the one used in Brooks shoes. This system helps ensure that the shoe remains stable and supportive without feeling overly stiff or heavy.
The midsoles of the React Infinity Run Flyknit 3 are designed to be three times denser than those of other running shoes, providing your feet with ample cushioning and support. The insole foam midfoot and foam wedge at the heel ensure that your feet stay comfortable and stable, while the breathable mesh uppers help keep your feet cool and dry.
The React Infinity Run Flyknit 3 also features Nike's waffle texture, which provides excellent traction on any surface, making it a great shoe for runners who like to run on roads, trails, or indoor tracks.
With a movement-responsive front and a comfortable cushioning system, this shoe is ideal for runners looking for a shoe that is versatile and adaptable. It has an 8mm drop and weighs in at 9.2 oz for women, making it a lightweight option for runners who prioritize speed and agility.
If you're looking for a shoe with even more stability and support, consider the Nike Zoom Structure line-up. This line features a range of stability shoes that offer excellent support and structure without compromising on comfort or cushioning.
For runners who want even more cushioning and support, the Saucony Guide is a great option. This shoe is designed to provide ample cushioning and support while remaining lightweight and flexible. With a wrap-around upper that provides additional stability and security, the Guide is a great option for runners who want a little extra support without feeling overly constricted.
Whether you're looking for a supportive-neutral shoe like the Nike React Infinity Run Flyknit 3, a stability shoe like the Nike Zoom Structure, or a cushioned shoe like the Saucony Guide, there are plenty of great options out there for runners of all levels. And with great return policies from companies like Nike, it's easy to try out different shoes and find the one that works best for you.
Broader Widths and Optimal Cushion: The New Balance Fresh Foam X 860
Experience stability and alignment like never before with the New Balance Fresh Foam 860 v13, which features a dual-density medial post in the midsole to combat overpronation and maintain your foot strike. The firm midsole is perfect for faster runs, while a combination of soft and hard rubbers on the outsole provides grip.
New Balance's latest V12 model offers the same smooth ride as the previous version, but with significant improvements to the upper. Made of a single-piece mesh with embroidered details, the breathable design keeps your feet cool and secure. And the cushioning is unparalleled.
This lightweight stability running shoe boasts a stretchy, spacious forefoot and toe box that feels snug but not constricting. With a 10 mm heel drop, 8.6 oz weight for women and 10.9 oz for men, and exceptional cushioning, the Fresh Foam 860 is perfect for runs of 3 to 20 miles.
One note: Fresh Foam has an array of numbered shoes, with the 880 being a neutral cushion option and the 860 representing the stability option.
Check out pricing and current colors on Road Runner Sports (VIP members get instant discounts) >>Compare pricing on Amazon (note that returns may be more difficult).
The Lightest Stability Shoe: HOKA Clifton
It's no surprise that the HOKA Clifton makes an appearance on a list of running shoes for overpronation - it's been a staple in many running shoe reviews. While the Clifton is not a stability shoe per se, the wider shoe base provides a natural stability effect, making it a favorite for many runners.
The HOKA Clifton 9 is the newest iteration, but as of publication, we'll focus on the Clifton 8. Having run in multiple models, I can confirm that the Clifton remains consistent from version 6 onward.
With its lack of posts or other support structures, the Clifton is likely the lightest option on this list. It offers a 5mm heel drop and weighs 7.2 oz for women and 8.9 oz for men. This moderate cushion option is ideal for runners with wide feet.
Browse the HOKA Clifton models and colors >>
Remember, older models are often cheaper and just as great if you aren't yet sold on the maximal shoe trend.
Discovering the Altra Provision 7's Stability
Upon receiving the Altra Provision, I was unaware that it was a stability shoe. But after testing it alongside a few other Altra models, its stability became quite clear.
This actually delighted me, as it meant that the shoe did not impose any immediate changes upon my stride. Rather, it allowed me to complete a comfortable and familiar run before I was able to compare and contrast its stability to that of other shoes.
Normally, overpronation can be corrected by the natural ability of your foot to widen its base and spread out. But this can only be achieved through regularly performing targeted foot-strengthening exercises, in conjunction with other self-improvement steps.
In terms of cushioning, the Altra Provision 7 sits snugly in the middle. I personally opted to continue using it, instead of switching to the Escalante with less cushioning or the Olympus with considerably more.
This zero drop shoe weighs 8.2 ounces for women and 9.6 ounces for men, boasting moderate cushioning that is particularly well-suited for those with wider feet. Interested buyers can explore earlier versions of the product by checking prices on Amazon.
Overall, the Altra Provision 7 is an excellent starting point for runners dealing with overpronation. And if you are committed to fully addressing the issue, consider reading through a few more helpful articles.
Connect with Amanda through other channels:
- Enjoy entertaining fitness content on Instagram: RunToTheFinish
Join the running community on Facebook: RunToTheFinish
Add some humor to your inbox by signing up for our weekly newsletter featuring top running tips and laughs: Subscribe now!
